Table of Contents:
Previous Post: Day 22 – Tampoe Tsho To Rerethang Via Thampe La
- The Walk From Rerethang To Upper Sephu
- End of Trip Celebration at Upper Sephu
- The Tipping Issue
- The Trek Operators: World Expedition and Yangphel
- Breakdown of Trek Cost For An “International” Tourist
- Bypassing The Foreign Agency To Savey $
- Group Size
- Links To the Complete Day-By-Day Snowman Trek Report
- My View of Bhutan;s “High Value, Low Impact” Tourism Policy
- The Continued Promotion of a False Narrative
- Contrasting Views On The Cost of Visiting Bhutan
- July 2022 Bhutan Tourism Policy Update- a $200. a day Tax!
The Walk From Rerethang To Upper Sephu
- Date: Sunday, October 20 (The trek began on September 28!)
- Time: 5 hours
- Distance: 13 km.
- Start point altitude: Rerethang 3670 m
- Endpoint altitude: Upper Sephu 2876m
For the past few evenings, dinner time conversation had centered increasingly on our plans after we finished the trek. Plane connections, work commitments, future trips … all signs that the end was near! Over the past three weeks, we had walked over 300 kilometers through some pretty crappy weather (the first ten days) and over some fairly rough terrain, challenging even to yaks and horses, never mind trekkers! We had also walked into some stunning vistas, and in the last half of the trek, the peaks would often be in full view and not be shrouded in cloud cover.
Almost all 16 of us made it, though one dropped out in Laya with a severe respiratory issue and another on Day 21 with a stomach problem.
We had one last section – the 13 kilometers from Rerethang to the endpoint at Upper Sephu. We had left the alpine; the morning would start on the west side trail down the Nikka Chhu across relatively flat and open terrain. The satellite image below shows the stretch from Rerethang to Maurothang. It was easy walking.
After Maurathang, we crossed to the east side, and the trail mostly went across the forested slopes. We were 50 or 100 meters above the river as we made our way south. Along the way, we also crossed several streams that tumble down to the Nikka Chhu -either rock hopping our way across or making use of the wooden bridges.
The red line on the satellite image below approximates our route down the Nikka Chhu from Maurothang to Upper Sephu. It took about 3 1/2 hours at a brisk pace to get done. In the process, we dropped another 800 meters in elevation. We had not been below 3000 meters in three weeks!
Somewhere along the way, I had my first hard fall of the trip! 22 days without incident, and an hour before the end, I placed my right boot on a sloped wet rock only to have it slip down. I lost my balance, and somehow the right side of my rib cage bumped hard into a rock. The trekking poles I always have in my hands helped somewhat reduce the fall’s severity, but it still hurt. It was mild enough that I could keep on walking, but every once in a while, there would be a stab of pain if I moved in the wrong way.
[It took about three weeks for the pain to go away. Back in Toronto, I had trouble lifting my right leg over the top tube of my bicycle. And then one day – no pain! Don’t you just love how time itself is often the answer, at least in the short run!]
The Celebration at Upper Sephu
Upper Sephu is at the end of a dirt road that winds its way up the east side of the Nikka Chhu from the Bumthang-Ura highway and Sephu proper. A few years ago, this road did not exist, and trekkers walked right to the highway and the Nikka Chhu bridge, another six or seven kilometers away.
We were greeted there by the Yangphel support team. They had arranged lunch for us, with bottles of wine and beer and a celebratory cake. There we are, sitting at our table!
I gathered some of the leftover bits of meat and gave a local dog watching the proceedings a surprise treat. But then, maybe it wasn’t a surprise! He may have learned that gatherings like ours often result in some freebies!
Not keen on dealing with the impact of even a bit of alcohol on my head while we spent the next four hours rocking back and forth on the bus, I decided to postpone my reintroduction to beer until that evening. On the table was a bottle of Bhutan’s finest red wine. Later that evening, I ended up ordering a can of tonic water! Fun guy!
The Tipping Issue
Tipping is always a big deal at the end of these treks. Over the past three evenings, the World Expeditions guide had
- collected some U.S.$300. to $400. from each of the 16 trekkers and
- come up with a formula to calculate each support staff member’s share based on their role.
The tip – and the concern about it shown by the guides from Day 1 – was just another reminder of economic reality trumping what is ultimately the nonsense of the Gross National Happiness concept concocted by Thimphu’s political elite on behalf of the vast majority of Bhutan’s citizens. The speeches made, thanks given, a few group photos of the support crew and their trekker guests, final handshakes and hugs …
The Trek Operators: World Expeditions/Yangphel
World Expeditions was the Australia-based adventure travel company that
- organized the trip,
- created an attractive webpage detailing the trek,
- brought together the 16 trekkers,
- ensured that visa and other issues were dealt with,
- worked with the local adventure travel agency, Yangphel, to ensure that specific standards were met, and
- assigned one of its own guides to accompany the local guide.
I was told that WE has been using Yangphel to handle its Snowman trip for the past two years.
The two decades’ worth of experience with high-altitude trekking and Himalayan climbing that the WE-assigned guide – Angel Armesto – had was a bonus. The local guide – Tandin Gyeltshen – assigned by Yangphel was also very experienced and knowledgeable, thanks to his twenty years of handling all sorts of tours. He had done birding tours and various trekking routes, including the Snowman Trek a dozen times. Both were just nice guys who made the trip more enjoyable.
Breakdown of Trek Costs For an International Tourist
- $7800 + $400 tip is what the trek cost me.
- $6750 (27 days x $250) went to the local trekking agency and to the Bhutanese government. The Bhutanese charge their “high value, low impact” (that is, non-Indian) tourists US $250. a day to be in Bhutam.
- $1755 for the entire 27-day stay was the Bhutanese government”sustainable development fee” ($65 a day!)
- $5000 – what he trekking agency got per trekker
- $1050 per trekker – the World Expeditions charge for making the trip happen and to pay for the salary of their own assigned guide.
- $400 The “voluntary” tip expected by all
See this Lonely Planet article (here) on money matters in Bhutan.
Add in US$2000. for airfare and airport taxis; another $200. for 2 nights at a decent hotel not far from Indira Gandhi Airport. My Snowman Trek is the most expensive trip I have ever done and will never be surpassed!
Note: In July 2022, the Bhutan Government raised the daily Sustainable Development Fee from $65 to $200! This adds another $3645 to the final cost of the 27-day trek. The price posted on the WE website is now $16900. US, more than double what it was in 2019!
Meanwhile, the KE Adventure Travel Snowman Trek at $13,265 has clearly included the new SDF. The KE price also includes two nights in a Kathmandu hotel ($250) plus the $650 flight from Kathmandu to Paro and back.
Bypassing The Foreign Travel Agency To Save $$
While you could just arrange the trek yourself through a Bhutanese agency, the problem is one of numbers. You would need to find at least one and preferably two or three other trekkers who would be willing to commit to the trip at the same time as you. Thanks to its attractive website, World Expeditions and other companies like it do the finding of trekking mates for you. That is worth at least a couple of hundred dollars. A solo traveller pays an extra $40. a day; a couple would each have to pay $30 extra. There are benefits to being with a larger group!
Our Trek Size of 16
However, a group size of 16 trekkers is not ideal. Consider the three previous organized treks I have done –
- Tanzania – Kilimanjaro eight-day Lemosho route 5 clients
- Bolivia – Cordillera Real Traverse– 15 days 7 clients
- Nepal – Upper Mustang-Phu Valley Traverse 5 clients
There were almost as many trekkers on this Snowman trek as on my previous three combined! With 43 horses and a dozen support staff, we were a small village on the move!
See the end of this post for more on Bhutan’s no-longer-functioning “high value, low impact” tourism policy.
By 1:30, we trekkers would hop into the bus pictured below. Destination – Punakha and what would be a newly-built 3-star hotel (the Zhingkham Resort) on the slopes on the west side of the Mo River. Showers, wifi, email, food choices, and food choices other than the trek food I had seen enough of …
The Complete Day-By-Day Snowman Trip Report!
- Bhutan’s Snowman Trek Preview: Part 1 – Paro To Shana To Laya
- Bhutan’s Snowman Trek Preview: Part 2 – Laya To Chozo To Upper Sephu
- Day 1 – Paro To Shana To Thongo Samba
- Day 2 – Thongo Samba Thangthangkha
- Day 3 – Thangthangkha To Jomolhari Base Camp
- Day 4 – Rest Day/Acclimatization Day at Jomolhari B.C.
- Day 5 – Jomolhari B.C. To Lingshi Via Nyile La
- Day 6 – Lingshi To Chebisa
- Day 7 – Chebisa To Shomuthang Via Gombu La
- Day 8 – Shomuthang To Robluthang Via Jare La
- Day 9 – Robluthang To Limithang Via Sinche La
- Day 10 – Limithang To Laya Village
- Day 11 – Rest Day In Laya Village
- Day 12 – Laya To Rodophu
- Day 13 – Rodophu To Narethang Via Tsemo La
- Day 14 – Narethang To Tarina Via Kang Karchung La
- Day 15 – Tarina To Green Lake Via Woche
- Day 16 – Green Lake To Tshojo Via Keche La
- Day 17 – Rest Day in Chozo (Tshojo)
- Day 18 – Chozo To Tsho Chena Via Sintia La
- Day 19 – Tsho Chena To Jichu Dramo Via Loju La
- Day 20 – Jichu Dramo To Tsho Tsho Tshampa Via Rinchen Zoe La
- Day 21 – Tsho Tsho Thampa To Tampoe Tsho
- Day 22 – Tampoe Tsho To Rerethang Via Tempe La
- Day 23 – Rerethang To Upper Sephu
Bhutan’s “High value, low volume/ impact” Policy:
Tourism Policy Before July 2022:
Only citizens of India, Bangladesh, and the Maldives can tour Bhutan on their own as “unregulated” visitors. Many enter Bhutan in their own vehicles. No visas are required. Meanwhile, “international” visitors must enter via Paro International Airport on Bhutan’s Druk Airlines. Since Drukair has a monopoly on flights into Paro Airport, its prices are rather steep. In May 2019, I paid
- 1595.CDN for an Air Canada Toronto-Delhi return ticket – 12000 kilometers
- $864.CDN for my Drukair New Delhi- Paro return ticket. 1,200 kilometers
On arrival, the “international” tourist must be in the care of a local travel agency and an assigned guide. They will also have paid $40. for the entry visa. They cannot rent a vehicle, bus from town to town, or trek alone.
Indian citizens – they account for 92% of the “unregulated” regional tourists – are exempt from the mandatory $250. tour package a day that other visitors must pay.
For the “international” visitors, a mandatory all-inclusive package deal of $250. a day is required to enter the country.
- $185. goes to a local travel agency that handles the visitors’ mandatory tour package – transport, food, accommodation, cultural center entrance fees, guides, etc.
- a $65-a-day government tax or ‘Sustainable Development Fee’
- Solo travellers can add an extra $40. a day; a party of two will pay an additional $30.-a-day surcharge for each person.
The Bhutanese government’s intent a half-century ago was to prevent the country from becoming a low-budget hippy backpacker destination like neighbouring Nepal. The tourism policy has been described as “high value, low volume/ impact.”
However, the past decade has seen this controlled tourism policy shattered. The graphs above and below illustrate the reason. As India’s middle class has grown more affluent, so has the number of Indian visitors.
Indeed, the growth since 2010 has been so dramatic that the “high value, low impact” policy has been swamped by a competing approach – “low value, high volume/impact.”
The stats below show that while the “high value” number of arrivals pre-COVID was reasonably stable, the number of Indian arrivals has skyrocketed.
See the article Bhutan throws up paywall amid surge of Indian tourists from The Hindu (2019). The writer examines the tensions created by the current setup with two opposing tourism goals.
The way it works now is that you’ve got to be financially well-off and, as a result, probably an older person ( 45 years +) to visit Bhutan – or have an Indian passport! My trekking group’s average age was in the low 50s! Most were lawyers, doctors, company execs…these were not “budget” travellers!
In 12019, the average Indian tourist spent about $50. per day compared to the $250. that “high value” tourists did. [See here for the data source. Interestingly, the one statistical chart absent from the study is the most obvious one, which shows the dramatic rise in “low value, high volume” tourism! ]
In 2019, 315,599 tourists visited Bhutan. Of that
- 72, 199 were of the “high value, low impact” class, up less than 1% from the previous year.
- 243,400 were in the “unregulated” regional category, up 20% from 2018.
To be fair, the large numbers of “unregulated” regional tourists will almost all be in the urban centers and temples and not on the trekking trails, perhaps because the agencies are more interested in catering to $165. a day “high-value” clients than those with more limited financial means.[It is the case, however, that some travel agencies have been making reduced-price deals with potential clients to get the business that would otherwise go to another agency. These deals are probably not being offered to “high value” guests!]
During the 23 days on the trek, we met one Swiss group in Lunana, a German couple in Laya, and a local student group at Komolhari B.C. That was it for traffic on the trail. It was, however, a different story at the Tiger’s Nest!
The Impact of Covid on Bhutanese Tourism:
The COVID-19 pandemic would have a devastating impact on Bhutan tourism. In 2020 arrivals dropped by 91 percent from 315,599 visitors in 2019 to 29,812. There was a 92% decline in gross receipts from the previous year! In 2021 first “high value, low impact” tourist arrived in September!
The Continued Promotion of a False Image of Bhutan
Despite the new reality, the Bhutanese government and travel agencies continue to promote the image of Bhutan as a “high value, low impact” destination. This government poster from 2019 pretends that all is good!
The poster also celebrates an off-the-cuff comment made by the King in the 1970s about “Gross National Happiness” which somehow became government policy a decade later! More than anything, it seems like a useful piece of fantasy concocted by the financially-well-off political elite in Thimphu to diffuse any political or social dissatisfaction.
Somehow we make a leap from the fluff of “Gross National Happiness” to the notion that the people of Bhutan are the happiest in the world – a statement that crops up in more than one tourism promo. Meanwhile, Bhutan ranks 129th in the U.N.’s Human Development Index (2019 stats – p.13 of 19). The Economist’s 2021 Democracy Index has Bhutan ranked 81st.
Credit must be given for its shift from a monarchy to what The Economist describes as a hybrid regime. Its 5.71 score in 2021 is far from the 2.62 it scored in 2006. However, the continued flattering of the members of the Wangchuk family for their “farseeing wisdom” by obsequious officials is a bit much to take.
An article –Tourism in Bhutan and COVID-19’s Lasting Impacts– from November 2020 – examines the state of Bhutanese tourism without acknowledging or factoring in the changes that have occurred since 2010, thanks to the massive influx of Indian tourists.
This Kuensel article –Promoting tourism at the World Expo– from January 2022 pretends that Bhutan’s tourism policy, the one developed by its “visionary kings” and grounded in the GNH concept, is still the “high cost, low impact” one of the 1990s and early 2000s!
Dorji Dradhul said that the tourism policy was far-sighted, crediting its success to the visionary Kings. “Our policy is grounded in our development policy of GNH.”
(He) interpreted the tourism policy as offering an unforgettable experience to the tourists, while also regulating the number of tourists visiting Bhutan.
Contrasting Views On The Cost of Visiting Bhutan
For an alternative view of Bhutan’s tourism policy – one which does not really address the contradiction between a mandatory $250. a day charge for 20% of its visitors and the next to no charge ($15.!) for the other 80%, see Is Bhutan really worth $250 per day? by a fellow WordPress blogger, a Dutch adventurer who was there pre-Covid.
For a counter-argument, consider the trekker Mark Horrell’s argument – “5 reasons why Bhutan is NOT worth the $200. per day tourist fee” from 2011. Since he wrote the piece, the cost has increased 25% to $250. Also, his opinion piece predates the massive influx of Indian tourists. In 2020 he would definitely have a sixth reason to add to his list.
The points he makes are quite valid. A three-week trek in Sagarmatha National Park in Nepal at
- one-third the cost with
- ten times the stupendous mountain views
is a much better deal.
The posts linked below look at The Three Passes of Everest Trek in Sagarmatha National Park in Nepal, which I would argue is the world’s #1 high-altitude trek. After my Bhutan experience, on top of many more Himalayan peaks and a vibrant Sherpa culture, I can add better weather and clear skies!
July 2022 Update: Bhutan’s Revamped Tourism Policy
I thought the Deutsche Welle website had made a typo error when I read that the daily “sustainable development fee” for non-Indian visitors to Bhutan had been raised from $65. a day to $200.
But no …. this New York Times article (July 5, 2022) explains the new direction in Bhutan’s tourism policy, one not hinted at in any of the articles mentioned above. This is a development that no one anticipated!
The NYT article uncritically echoes the happiness myth promoted by the Tourism Council of Bhutan and fails to mention that international visitors make up less than 25% of Bhutan’s visitors. It also does not note that the other 75% of Bhutan’s visitors – Indian tourists – will be charged a $ 15-a-day tax!
While the new policy will undoubtedly limit the number of tourists, “international” tourists will be especially affected. The exclusivity that “international” tourists are led to think their $200. a day fee was buying will conflict with the streams of Indian tourists they see in the towns and temples.
Since I was in Bhutan for 27 days to do the Snowman Trek, the new SDF would mean a US$5400 government tax just to be in Bhutan! Assuming that the local travel agency Yangphel will still charge $5000. for doing the trek, and the World Expeditions fee for arranging the trek is in the $1300 range, the Snowman Trek will now cost over US$11,000! I can spend three weeks in Sagarmatha National Park contemplating the world’s most impressive collection of 6000-meter plus peaks for one-third of that!
The TripAdvisor Bhutan Forum has information and links that help explain Bhutan’s revamped tourism policy.
The Tourism Council of Bhutan issued an in-depth explanation of the new tourism policy – The Tourism Rules and Regulations of Bhutan 2022